We're #1: Taking a look at new first issue comic books for 12/24/2025
Weekly Comic Book First Look: Key Issue Potential or Back Issue Bin? We dissect new #1 releases, analyzing art, story, and market buzz to predict which comics could become hot collectibles and which might fade into obscurity. Perfect for comic book investors and speculators!
Key or Filler?
In the expansive universe of comic books, new titles are frequently released, each with the potential to captivate readers in unique ways. Today, we will present a curated list of upcoming first issue comic book titles that are stirring excitement in the community. Which new #1 issues will you be picking up this week?
DC K.O.: Red Hood vs. The Joker #1
Superstar writers Scott Snyder and Joshua Williamson join forces for DC K.O.: Red Hood vs. The Joker #1, the brutal final round of the "All Fight Month" tournament that finally pits Jason Todd against the monster who murdered him. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as this high-stakes showdown features a rare creative collaboration between Snyder and Williamson and serves as a definitive turning point in the Red Hood/Joker rivalry that is guaranteed to drive long-term demand.
The Will of Doom #1
Marvel’s most iconic villain takes center stage in The Will of Doom #1, a massive new series launch that explores Victor Von Doom’s absolute rise to power as he reshapes the Marvel Universe in his own image. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as any new #1 from a superstar creative team for an iconic character like Doctor Doom, especially following his major cinematic announcements, has high potential for key story developments and will be a sought-after collectible.
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Battle Nexus #1
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Battle Nexus #1 kicks off a massive multiversal tournament that brings together iterations of the Turtles from across 40 years of media, including the Mirage Studios, 1987, 2003, and 2012 universes. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as this high-profile event series features the IDW debut of fan-favorite character Ninjara and serves as a significant crossover milestone that is guaranteed to drive long-term demand among TMNT enthusiasts and completionists.
Gray Lady #1
Gray Lady #1 is a chilling supernatural thriller from writers Adam Glass and Mike Benson that follows a grieving mother who, after being warned by a psychic that her late son is in danger, descends into a terrifying world to save him. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as it is a prestige 40-page horror debut from the "Ninth Circle" line and features the interior artwork of industry legend Ken Lashley, whose work on new independent properties often sees significant aftermarket interest.
Fire and Ice: Nekron #1
Fire and Ice: Nekron #1 unearths the twisted origin of the iconic fantasy villain, following Queen Juliana as her grief and black magic set in motion the tragic events that spell doom for the Realms of Ice and Fire. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as this premiere origin story is written by Frank Frazetta’s granddaughter, Sara Frazetta, and features the first appearance of the Wolf-God Ulghir, making it a high-potential key for fans of the legendary 1983 animated film.
Vale of Tears #1
Vale of Tears #1 reimagines the legendary Carthaginian general Hannibal Barca as a man on the run, blending historical drama with dark supernatural elements as the goddess Ishtar intervenes in his final, desperate days of exile. Collectors should keep a close eye on this premiere issue, as it is written by "The Church" frontman Steve Kilbey and features the meticulous artwork of industry veteran Keith Donald, creating a unique crossover appeal for both historical fiction fans and music memorabilia collectors.
Blues: Lore & Legends #1
Blues: Lore & Legends #1 delves into the crossroads of history and myth, weaving together the haunting tales of legendary blues musicians and the supernatural bargains that defined their music. This debut issue is a true toss-up: the unique intersection of musical history and dark folklore offers a sophisticated, prestige appeal that could capture a high-end collector market; however, as a non-traditional genre title from an independent publisher, its ability to generate mainstream heat remains unproven. Collectors will need to look into their crystal ball to determine if this rhythmic horror anthology becomes a soulful breakout hit or remains a quiet, melodic bust, making this first issue a true collector's gamble.
Do Not Disturb #1
Do Not Disturb #1 follows a weary traveler who checks into a secluded roadside motel, only to discover that the rhythmic thumping from the room next door is the heartbeat of an ancient, vengeful entity tied to a forgotten melody. This debut issue is a true toss-up: the atmospheric "hotel horror" trope blended with deep musical lore offers a sophisticated, prestige appeal that could capture a high-end collector market; however, as a quiet, psychological horror title from an independent publisher, its ability to generate the "hype" necessary for a secondary market boom remains unproven. Collectors will need to look into their crystal ball to determine if this haunting isolation story becomes a cult-classic breakout hit or remains a quiet, lonely bust, making this first issue a true collector's gamble.
Conclusion: Buy what makes you happy and have fun.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog post regarding potential key issues and comic book values is for entertainment and informational purposes only. The opinions expressed are based on our analysis and observations, and should not be considered financial advice. The comic book market is highly speculative and volatile, and past performance is not indicative of future results. We strongly encourage readers to conduct their own thorough research and consult with qualified professionals before making any purchasing decisions. Comic book collecting should be enjoyed as a hobby, and any financial gains or losses are the sole responsibility of the individual.