We're #1: Taking a look at new first issue comic books for 9/17/2025
Weekly Comic Book First Look: Key Issue Potential or Back Issue Bin? We dissect new #1 releases, analyzing art, story, and market buzz to predict which comics could become hot collectibles and which might fade into obscurity. Perfect for comic book investors and speculators!
Key or Filler?
In the expansive universe of comic books, new titles are frequently released, each with the potential to captivate readers in unique ways. Today, we will present a curated list of upcoming first issue comic book titles that are stirring excitement in the community. Which new #1 issues will you be picking up this week?
Marvel/D.C. Deadpool/Batman #1
The Merc with a Mouth lands in Gotham City, forcing a crossover with the Dark Knight in Marvel/DC: Deadpool/Batman #1, a historic one-shot that brings the two major comic publishers together for the first time in decades. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue as it's a landmark event and features multiple stories by a lineup of superstar creators, including the return of legendary artist Frank Miller to Batman. This could become a key issue in the near future.
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Casey Jones #1
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles fan-favorite Casey Jones gets his first solo mini-series in over three decades in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Casey Jones #1, an action-packed book that finds the vigilante taking to the streets to protect New York City. This comic is a potential key issue for collectors because it introduces a brand-new villains into the TMNT universe, and it’s a #1 issue for a beloved character that is part of a successful ongoing series.
Star Wars: Boba Fett - Black, White & Red #1
Boba Fett finds himself trapped between the Empire and a rogue Rebel faction while hunting a bounty in Star Wars: Boba Fett - Black, White & Red #1, a new anthology series that follows in the footsteps of previous popular Darth Vader and Darth Maul titles. This comic could become a key issue for speculators and collectors as it is a new #1 for a fan-favorite character, features a high-profile creative team, and boasts numerous collectible variant covers.
Batman Day 2025: Absolute Batman #1
Legendary creators Scott Snyder and Nick Dragotta unite for Batman Day 2025: Absolute Batman #1, a brutal new saga that reveals Batman's final mission: to unite all of Gotham's broken parts. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as any new #1 from a superstar creative team for an iconic character like Batman, especially as a special Batman Day release, has high potential for key story developments and will be a sought-after collectible.
Marvel Zombies: Red Band #1
An undead plague infects the Marvel Universe from its very inception in Marvel Zombies: Red Band #1, a new series that rewrites iconic Marvel history with explicit gore and horror. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as it's a new "Red Band" title that is polybagged for its mature content and arrives just before the new Marvel Zombies animated series that debuts on Disney+ on September 24th.
The Bat-Man: Second Knight #1
A new murder spree has gripped Gotham City in The Bat-Man: Second Knight #1, as a mysterious killer with a mastery of fear uses a hangman's noose as their calling card. Collectors should keep a close eye on this issue, as it is the first in a new series following the breakout hit The Bat-Man: First Knight, features the first appearance of a new villain, and includes the arrival of a Golden Age Lois Lane in Gotham.
No Man's Land #1
A chilling murder mystery set during the Cold War, No Man's Land #1 follows an FBI agent and a KGB operative who must solve a murder on an icy no-man's land between the USA and Russia. This comic is a true gamble for speculators because as an original IP from an independent publisher, its success is uncertain and you'll need to look into your own crystal ball to see if it will "boom" or "bust".
The Last Day of H.P. Lovecraft #1
A "dreamlike" story that explores the final journey of H.P. Lovecraft on the last day of his life is at the center of The Last Day of H.P. Lovecraft #1, a new series adapted from a hit French graphic novel. This comic is a true gamble for speculators because as an adaptation, its success is uncertain and depends on whether it can find a new audience, so you'll need to look into a crystal ball to know if it will "boom" or "bust".
Conclusion: Buy what makes you happy and have fun.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog post regarding potential key issues and comic book values is for entertainment and informational purposes only. The opinions expressed are based on our analysis and observations, and should not be considered financial advice. The comic book market is highly speculative and volatile, and past performance is not indicative of future results. We strongly encourage readers to conduct their own thorough research and consult with qualified professionals before making any purchasing decisions. Comic book collecting should be enjoyed as a hobby, and any financial gains or losses are the sole responsibility of the individual.